Fall 2009 First Impressions: A Certain Scientific Railgun

Mikoto or Kuroko? Mikoto or Kuroko? Hmm, Mikoto was my favorite character from A Certain Magical Index, but I loved the few moments Kuroko got screentime. Now that she’s going to get more screentime… I’m going with Kuroko! She’s deliciously yuri and anti-Touma to boot! So I will not tread on Mikotoism’s territory.

I like Kuroko for her mind

Fansub group: Mazui

Things I liked:

  • Love the voice work. It’s also interesting hearing Kanae Itou as Saten, because Mii-chan was the first role I heard her in, and Saten is a much different character.
  • No Touma, no Index. More Mikoto, more Kuroko is a recipe for awesomeness.
  • Character designs are great, animation is solid. It’s pretty much the same high quality that we saw from Magical Index.

Things I didn’t like:

  • There really wasn’t much I disliked from this episode. Mazui unfortunately didn’t include the OP, so I didn’t get to see it, but the brief glimpse of Touma in the ED was more than enough. Ugh, the thought of him showing up to ruin this show really bums me out. Maybe they’ll give him some sort of magical condition that turns him into a mute.

Random other thoughts:

That shower scene was an awesome moment, and I was really tempted to put the screenshot up, but this is a family friendly blog. And uh, I don’t want to end up in jail like Zyl.

Welcome back Mikoto – by far the most interesting character from Magical Index. Even though this is Mikoto’s show, it seemed like there wasn’t that much focus on her. I imagine this show is eventually going to get an overarching plotline that carries it through the season, but I actually really liked the standalone style of the first episode. I think this would be a show where it could be just as interesting as a series of disconnected episodics.

I wonder if we’ll see MISAKA, Last Order and Accelerator at any point this season. That was the second most interesting arc of Magical Index, sans the stupid ending.

A Certain Scientific Railgun was one of the few series that I was actually anticipating this season, and the first episode delivered everything I wanted: RAEGING YURI from Kuroko (actually, I thought she was pretty restrained), a lot of lighthearted, funny moments, a little bit of action-flick bombast, and a good amount of fanservice. I’m definitely going to watch this one, and am considering writing about it. My hesitations are a.) whether or not this is a 24+ episode season, and b.) my previous experience writing about Magical Index. To be fair, it was when I was just getting started, and I didn’t exactly know what I was doing. And the show really sucked in the beginning. But that experience gave me bad memories. However, with a new director, maybe this spinoff won’t suffer from the same issues (bland storytelling and terrible pacing) like the original. We’ll see how it goes in the second ep. Maybe I’ll use Railgun as a testing ground for different posting styles.

12 Replies to “Fall 2009 First Impressions: A Certain Scientific Railgun”

    1. lol, this is probably not a family-friendly blog to begin with anyway. 😀

      Nope, haven’t read the manga. Index is a light novel, but Railgun is a manga?

  1. “Mazui unfortunately didn’t include the OP, so I didn’t get to see it, but the brief glimpse of Touma in the ED was more than enough.”

    Only my railgun is actually the OP for this, but I have no idea why it was broadcasted as the ED for this episode…

  2. I enjoyed this first episode, too. Agreed that the standalone style of this episode is cool. It is a nice way to ease people back into the world of Index. Love Misaka, and I like the new characters quite a bit, too. Plus, more badass railgun action. Hell yes.

    1. As long as Railgun doesn’t try to do too much with its story I think it’ll be good. I remember Index introducing this big story of conspiracies, and then being frustrated, because they’d then show whole series of arcs that had nothing to do with the main story. I know it only covered a few of the books, but the direction was absolutely horrendous, IMO.

      1. Definitely. That’s what makes the final arc particularly disappointing — it really comes off like a story that should be in the middle of the season rather than something to close things out. If it had been anything but a season-closing arc it might have been fine, but … yeah.

  3. The “ED” was actually the OP; Gundam 00 season two did that for the first episode — along with a few other series — too.

    Well, here I am opposite everyone else again. I hated this episode. I thought the direction was terrible, and the show has none of the kick that Index did. It was a complete letdown for me. I guess I’ll explain more when I get back to posting on my blog again…
    .-= Michael | Low on Hit Points´s last blog ..BlazBlue is the best 2d fighter ever, rendering almost all of the competition obsolete =-.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.